Nolan Schanuel - VOID

[St. Louis Cardinals]

4+ years/$0.50

[SDP - Jere]

$1 x 4 years

[CWS]

He should be in the rookie draft as he was drafted last year

[St. Louis Cardinals]

Jan 22, 2024 8:18:52 GMT -5 CWS said:

He should be in the rookie draft as he was drafted last year

He also got MLB action starting in August, so I thought that made him eligible. If that’s not the case, my bad.

[St. Louis Cardinals]

4 years/$1.10

[LA Dodgers]

Jan 22, 2024 8:36:09 GMT -5 St. Louis Cardinals said:

Jan 22, 2024 8:18:52 GMT -5 CWS said:

He should be in the rookie draft as he was drafted last year

He also got MLB action starting in August, so I thought that made him eligible. If that’s not the case, my bad.

Unless I'm missing it, I don't see anything in the rules that says if a player gets MLB AB's in the same year he was drafted, that it makes him eligible to be auctioned.  I couldn't remember any case of this happening myself.  But I was reminded that Garrett Crochet did it a few years ago.  What did we do then?

I think he is still ineligible to be auctioned since there is nothing specific in the rules.  But we should let commish make this final decision.

[Baltimore Orioles]

He didn’t hit his at bats threshold I am pretty sure he is considered a prospect still.

[Oakland Athletics]

Players like this have always been ineligible to be auctioned. Just like Crochet. I will have to thumb through the rules if there is nothing specific then we will need to fix that, but any player like this has always been ineligible so we will continue that.

[St. Louis Cardinals]

Jan 22, 2024 11:53:08 GMT -5 Oakland Athletics said:

Players like this have always been ineligible to be auctioned. Just like Crochet. I will have to thumb through the rules if there is nothing specific then we will need to fix that, but any player like this has always been ineligible so we will continue that.

Fair enough! My mistake.

[Cincinnati Reds]

I drafted Crochet